Protein Quality: Why Your Body Doesn't Care About the Label

If you're serious about building muscle, you've probably asked: "How much protein should I eat?" But there's a more important question nobody asks: "How much of that protein actually builds muscle?"

The answer might surprise you. A 30-gram serving of chicken breast delivers nearly twice the usable muscle-building protein as 30 grams from wheat bread—despite identical labels. This is the hidden variable in your nutrition: protein quality.

New 2025 research confirms what scientists have suspected: it's not just about how much protein you eat—it's about how much your body can actually use.

The Problem With Nutrition Labels

Here's the uncomfortable truth: nutrition labels tell you total protein, not usable protein.

Your muscles don't process protein like a calculator. They need specific amino acids—particularly the nine essential amino acids your body cannot produce on its own. When you eat protein, your body must:

• Digest it into individual amino acids
• Absorb those amino acids through your intestinal wall
• Utilize them for muscle protein synthesis (MPS)

A protein source can look great on paper but fail at any of these steps. This is where PDCAAS and DIAAS come in—scientific scoring systems that measure how well a protein actually performs.

What Is PDCAAS?

PDCAAS (Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score) was developed by the FDA and WHO in 1989 and served as the gold standard for over two decades.

The scoring works like this:

• Amino acid profile: Compares the protein's essential amino acids to human requirements
• Limiting amino acid: Identifies the weakest link—the essential amino acid in shortest supply
• Fecal digestibility: Measures how much protein reaches your colon (not ideal, but it was the best available)
• Final score: Limiting amino acid score × digestibility (capped at 100)

PDCAAS Scores of Common Proteins

| Protein Source | PDCAAS Score | Notes | |----------------|--------------|-------| | Whey, Casein, Egg, Chicken, Fish | 100 | Complete, highly digestible | | Soy Protein Isolate | 100 | Best plant protein | | Pea Protein | 89 | Lysine-limited | | Chickpeas | 78 | Methionine-limited | | Wheat | 42 | Lysine-limited | | Rice | 47 | Lysine-limited |

The problem? Many proteins cap at 100, making it impossible to distinguish between genuinely excellent sources and merely "good enough" ones.

Enter DIAAS: The New Gold Standard

DIAAS (Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score) was recommended by the FAO in 2013 and represents a major upgrade:

• Ileal digestibility: Measures absorption in the small intestine (where it actually matters), not the colon
• Individual amino acid tracking: Assesses each essential amino acid separately
• No 100-point cap: Scores can exceed 100, allowing real differentiation
• More accurate for plants: Better reflects true bioavailability

DIAAS Scores (2025 Data)

| Protein Source | DIAAS Score | Quality Rating | |----------------|-------------|-----------------| | Whey Protein Isolate | 109-114 | Excellent | | Milk Protein | 114-118 | Excellent | | Egg | 100 | Excellent | | Beef | 92 | Excellent | | Soy Protein Isolate | 91-99 | Good | | Pea Protein Isolate | 82-89 | Good | | Rice Protein | 37-47 | Low |

Sources: [FAO 2014](https://www.fao.org/ag/human-nutrition/36249-0892e5a9a64d5b7c9c1d5c8e5d3e8d2b7.pdf), [Glanbia Nutritionals 2025](https://www.glanbianutritionals.com/en/nutri-knowledge-center/nutritional-resources/spectrum-protein-quality)

The 23% Muscle Growth Difference

Here's why this matters for your gains.

Researchers at the University of Illinois demonstrated that consuming high-DIAAS proteins resulted in 23% greater 24-hour muscle protein synthesis compared to lower-DIAAS proteins when total protein was equated.

That's enormous. You're leaving roughly a quarter of your potential muscle growth on the table simply by choosing lower-quality protein sources—even if you're hitting your gram targets.

Why Does This Happen?

• Complete amino acid profile: Animal proteins contain all nine essential amino acids in adequate amounts. Plant proteins often lack one or more (typically lysine in grains, methionine in legumes).

• Better digestibility: Animal proteins are 90-95% digestible. Plant proteins range from 70-90%, with fiber and anti-nutrients further reducing absorption.

• Faster MPS response: High-DIAAS proteins trigger a stronger, faster muscle protein synthesis response, particularly important post-workout.

Practical Applications

For Muscle Building

Prioritize DIAAS ≥ 100 proteins for your post-workout meal:

• Whey protein (109-114 DIAAS)
• Eggs (100 DIAAS)
• Chicken, fish, beef (92-100 DIAAS)
• Greek yogurt, cottage cheese

These maximize your MPS response when muscle building is the priority.

For Plant-Based Lifters

If you eat plant-based, combine proteins strategically:

• Rice + beans: Complementary amino acids (rice adds methionine missing in beans, beans add lysine missing in rice)
• Pea + rice protein: Creates a complete amino profile
• Soy: The exception—it's a high-quality plant protein at 91-99 DIAAS

Consider a 20-30% higher total protein intake when relying primarily on plant proteins to account for lower digestibility and incomplete profiles.

During Caloric Restriction

When cutting, protein quality becomes even more critical. With limited calories, every gram must count. Research shows high-DIAAS proteins help preserve lean mass during fat loss phases better than lower-quality options.

For Athletes Over 40

Age-related declines in anabolic sensitivity mean older athletes need more usable protein. Studies from McMaster University show the quality difference becomes even more critical after 40.

The Bottom Line

• Total protein intake still matters — you're not off the hook for hitting 1.6-2.2 g/kg
• Quality matters MORE than previously thought — aim for DIAAS >100 when possible
• Animal proteins outperform plant proteins — but strategic plant combinations work
• Post-workout is prime time — use your highest-quality protein after training

The era of "protein is protein" is over. Your muscles are picky eaters. Feed them what they actually want.

---

References:

• [FAO. Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition (2013)](https://www.fao.org/ag/human-nutrition/36249-0892e5a9a64d5b7c9c1d5c8e5d3e8d2b7.pdf)
• [University of Illinois - High DIAAS Protein Study (2025)](https://fitnessrec.com/articles/protein-quality-for-athletes-pdcaas-and-diaas-scoring-systems-explained)
• [Glanbia Nutritionals - Spectrum of Protein Quality (2025)](https://www.glanbianutritionals.com/en/nutri-knowledge-center/nutritional-resources/spectrum-protein-quality)
• [Jäger et al., ISSN Position Stand (2017)](https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12970-017-0177-8)